Should Your Business Be Doing Reels? Check Your Numbers First

Every marketing account on the planet seems to be telling you the same thing. Do reels. Video is king. Post more, film more, dance if you have to.

Meanwhile you’re running a business. You’ve got jobs booked, quotes to write, an invoice that’s three weeks overdue and a phone that doesn’t stop. The idea of learning to film and edit videos on top of all that is, frankly, a bit much.

Here’s the good news. Before you spend a single evening learning video editing, you can find out whether it’s even worth doing for your business. You just need to check your own numbers.

Why everyone says it works isn’t good enough

Most social media advice is written for everyone, which means it’s written for no one in particular. What works for a fashion brand or a fitness influencer isn’t necessarily what works for a builder in Tauranga or a cleaner in Hamilton.

We learned this ourselves. We made seven reels. They got 0 saves, 0 follows and 0 profile visits. We followed the advice to the letter, and it did sod all for us.

Meanwhile, a plain post about ads going wrong kept getting shown to people who had never heard of us. No video required.

That’s the point. The format matters far less than whether it works for your audience. And the only way to know that is to look.

The numbers that actually matter

Views are the number everyone looks at first, and on their own they’re the least useful. A view just means someone’s thumb slowed down for a second. It doesn’t mean they cared.

Here’s what to look at instead:

  • Saves. Someone thought your post was worth coming back to. That’s a strong signal.
  • Follows. Someone saw your post and wanted more. That’s growth.
  • Profile visits. Someone wanted to know who you are. That’s curiosity, and it’s often the step before an enquiry.
  • Reach to non followers. Instagram shows you how much of your reach came from people who don’t already follow you. If that’s tiny, you’re mostly talking to the same crowd.

And of course, the one that pays the bills: did anyone message you, call or fill in a form because of it?

Watch out for cross posting

This one caught us out, and it catches out loads of small businesses.

If you share your Instagram posts to Facebook automatically, your view count can include views from both. That makes things look healthier than they are. When we pulled our reels apart, a big chunk of the views came from Facebook. On the newest one, more than half did. On Instagram, those reels were mostly reaching people who already followed us.

So if you’re cross posting, split the numbers out. Look at each platform on its own. A decent total can hide a pretty flat result underneath.

How to run a quick audit of your own posts

You don’t need fancy software. Instagram’s own insights will do the job if you’ve got a professional or business account.

  1. Pick your last 10 to 20 posts. Enough to spot a pattern, not so many you lose the will to live.
  2. Write down the format of each. Reel, single image, carousel, whatever.
  3. Note the useful numbers. Saves, follows, profile visits, and how much reach came from non followers.
  4. Group them by format. Which type is actually reaching new people and getting them to do something?
  5. Look for surprises. Is there a plain post quietly outperforming everything else? Ask yourself why. Usually it’s because it was genuinely useful or answered a question people actually have.

Do this once and you’ll know more about your social media than most of the advice you’ve been reading.

Do more of what works, park the rest

Once you can see what’s working, the decision gets a lot easier. If reels are bringing you new followers and enquiries, brilliant, keep going. If they’re not, it’s okay to park them. You’re not failing at marketing. You’re making a sensible call based on evidence.

That’s exactly what we did. We’ve parked reels until we’ve got something worth filming, and we’re putting our energy into what the numbers show is working.

Your time is precious. Spend it on the stuff that brings in work.

Let’s look at yours together

If you’d rather not spend your Sunday arm deep in Instagram insights, that’s fair enough. Looking at numbers and working out what’s actually bringing in enquiries is literally our job.

Book a free discovery call and we’ll have an honest look at what you’re doing, what’s working and what you can stop worrying about. No pressure, just a straight chat: https://schedule.enquiremarketing.com/discovery-call

Want this done for you?

Ask for a free Leak Check and within 24 hours you’ll have a short, honest read on where your website, search and ads are leaking enquiries. It costs nothing and it is genuinely useful.